Killion vs MaxiFi: consumption smoothing versus a withdrawal rule

MaxiFi computes a sustainable living standard from lifetime resources (Kotlikoff-style consumption smoothing). Killion tests named withdrawal rules on seeded market paths. Both are retirement math. They are not the same question.

At a glance

Killion 1,000-path Monte Carlo projection with a probability of success
Killion's 1,000-path projection — the same engine the public demo runs. Account linking is the other half of the argument: read-only brokerage sync means the plan updates when the holdings do, which is the capability review-site roundups call "retirement planning software with account linking."
Killion wordmark
Killion
MaxiFi wordmark
MaxiFi

Killion is planning and simulation software with read-only account linking. MaxiFi is described below in its own terms. Where a figure is quoted it comes from the vendor's published pricing and was checked on the date shown.

 KillionMaxiFi
Individual price$14/mo, or $11/mo billed annually ($132/yr). Max tier $24/mo or $19/mo annually.Standard $109/yr. Premium $149/yr. Premium Plus $359/yr.
Monte Carlo1,000-path regime-switching Monte Carlo with fixed seeds, so a run reproduces.Living Standard Monte Carlo is listed on Premium, not Standard.
Question askedHow often does this withdrawal rule last on these paths?What living standard do lifetime resources support?
Tax / RothNot modelled.Roth Conversion Optimizer listed on Premium. Lifetime tax planning is the product’s centre.

MaxiFi details checked on against the MaxiFi pricing. Vendors change prices; verify before deciding.

Two questions

MaxiFi’s pricing page sells a lifetime financial plan, scenario comparison, retirement withdrawal and Social Security timing on Standard, and Living Standard Monte Carlo plus a Roth Conversion Optimizer on Premium. Killion’s public site sells named withdrawal rules, a seeded household Monte Carlo and read-only linking. Pick the question, then the tool.

Which one to choose

Choose Killion if

  • You want Guyton-Klinger, VPW or Vanguard dynamic on a public calculator, then the same family in a linked household.
  • You want the demo without buying a SKU to see Monte Carlo.

Choose MaxiFi if

  • You want consumption smoothing and US tax/Social Security optimisation as the plan, not a withdrawal-rule laboratory.

More comparisons

Frequently asked questions

How much is MaxiFi in 2026?
Standard $109 per year, Premium $149 per year, Premium Plus $359 per year, from maxifi.com/pricing on 28 August 2026.